Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutCAIOLA, SAL New•York State Department of Environmental Conservation Gj I a 50 Wolf Road, Albany, New York 9223a - 1550 MEN Thomas C.Jorling Commissioner CERTIFIED MAIL May 19 , 1988 Roy Haje En-Consultants, Inc. 1329 North Sea Road Southampton, NY . 11968 Re: SAL CAIOLA Decision Application No. 10-86-0647 Dear Mr. Haje : Enclosed is a copy of the Decision of the Department dated May 18 , 1988 in the above entitled matter. A copy of this Decision will be sent to the attorneys, individual parties, organizations, affected State agencies and units of local government who appeared at the hearing and other persons or organizations known or believed to have an interest in this Decision. Very rtruly yours, Robert S . Drew Chief Administrative Law Judge RHF/lm Enclosure cc: Sal Caiola ( Certified Mail ). Michael Greco, Esq. Henry P. Smith, President Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold STATE OF NEW YORK DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION 50 Wolf Road Albany, New York 12233-1550 I.n the Matter of the Application of SAL CAIOLA for a permit pursuant to the Environmental Conservation Law, Article 25 for a two-lot subdivision and for the installation of a shoreline stabilization structure on Long Island Sound, Village of Greenport, Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York . Application No. 10-86-0647 DECISION May 18, 1988 .j I y DECISION OF THE COMMISSIONER The attached Hearing Report ( the "Report" ) of Administrative Law Judge ( "ALJ" ) Samuel J. Kearing in the Matter of the Application of SAL CAIOLA ( the "Applicant" ) for a permit pursuant to Environmental Conservation Law ( "ECL" ) Article 25 ( the "Tidal Wetlands Act" ) to subdivide a parcel of land into two building lots and to erect a shoreline stabilization structure ( the "Project" ) in a regulated area adjacent to tidal wetlands in the Village of Greenport, Town of Southold, Suffolk. County, New York is ' hereby adopted as the Decision in this matter , subject to my comments below. The record demonstrates that the construction of the proposed steel wall could have a detrimental impact on the wetland and that, when in place, the wall might also cause erosion and scour during severe storms . Given the fact that the record shows no social or economic benefits from the construction of such a wall , I find that there may be an undue adverse impact on the present or potential value of the wetland. Accordingly the proposal for construction of the wall does not meet the standards for granting permits in adjacent areas ( see 6 NYCRR 661 . 10( c ) ) and must be denied. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Department of Environmental Conservation has caused this Decision to be signed and issued and has filed the same with all maps , plans, reports and other relevant document in its office in Albany this /8 day of May, 1988 . DEPART T OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION THOM C. JORLING, COMMISSIONER i i STATE OF NEW YORK DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION 50 Wolf Road Albany , New York 12233-1550 In the Matter of the Application - of - SAL CAIOLA for a permit pursuant to ECL , Article 25 to subdivide a shoreline parcel of 'land into two building lots and authoriz_.ng the installation of a shoreline stabilization structure on Long Island Sound in the Village of Greenport , Town of Southold , Suffolk County, New York. Application No . 10-86-0647 HEARING REPORT Prepared and Submitted by amuel J . -V�ary g Administrative/' Law Judge j i y PROCEEDINGS On September 11 , 1987 , a combined Notice of Complete Application and Notice of Hearing was issued by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation ( the "Department" ) in the matter of Sal Caiola ( the "Applicant" ) residing at 71 Lynn Avenue , Hampton Bays , New York 11946 , for permit application No . 10-86-0647 . The application proposed construction of a sheet steel retaining wall along the toe of a bluff on Long Island Sound ( the "Project" ) and the subdivision into two parcels of Applicant' s parcel of land ( the "Site" ) located in the Village of Greenport, Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York . The combined Notice of Complete Application and Hearing was published in the Long Island Traveler-Watchman, a weekly newspaper of general circulation in the Town of Southold, on September 24 , 1987 , and in the Department' s Environmental Notice Bulletin on September 23 , 1987 . Copies of the notices were sent y mail-to the clerks and chief executive officers of the municipalities within whose boundaries the Site is located, and to others who expressed interest in the proposed Project. Statutes and Regulations The permit application was filed and processed pursuant to the State Administrative Procedure Act and Environmental Conservation Law ( "ECL" ) Article 3 , Title 3 (General Functions ) ; Article 8 ( State Environmental Quality Review; Article 25 ( the "Tidal Wetlands Act" ) ; Article 70 (Uniform Procedures ) ; and pursuant to Title 6 of the Official Compilation of Codes , Rules and Regulations of the State of New York( "6 NYCRR" ) Part 616 ( State Environmental Quality Review Act "SEQRA" ) ; Part 621 (Uniform Procedures ) ; and Part 661 ; ( Tidal wetlands Land Use Regulations ) . The public hearing was held pursuant to Part 624 ( Permit Hearing Procedures ) . State Environmental Quality Review Act ( "SEQRA" ) On June 27 , 1986 , the Board of Trustees of the Town of Southold, as lead agency, issued a positive declaration pursuant to 6 NYCRR Part 617 for the proposed Project. Subsequently, on October 30 , 1986 , the Board reversed itself and issued a negative declaration for the proposed Project . Its determination was supported by the following reasons : "l . An environmental assessment from has been submitted which indicated that there would be no adverse effect to the environment should the project be implemented as planned. - 2 - "2 . Because there has been no response in the allotted time from the Southold Town Building Department and the New York State D. E.C. it is assumed that there are no objections or comments from those agencies . " The Hearing At the request of Department Staff, an adjudicatory public r hearing on the application convened before Administrative Law Judge ( "ALJ" ) Samuel J . Kearing on October 29 , 1987 in the E Southold Town Hall , 53095 Main Road, Southold, New York . Applicant Sal Caiola was represented by Mr . Roy L. Haje , j President, En-Consultants , Inc . , 1329 North Sea Road, Southampton, New York 11968 . In support of the proposed Project, Applicant called three witnesses: Charles F. Vachris , P . E . , a consulting engineer experienced in foundations and marine construction, Thomas Samuels, a marine contractor , and Mr . Haje , himself, a biologist . f Department Staff was represented by Michael Greco, Esq. , ! Assistant Regional Attorney, DEC Region I , Building 40 , SUNY, r Stony Brook, New York 11794 . The Department called two witnesses , Mr . Jean L. Gilman, the Department' s Regional Flood ; Plain Coordinator, and resident expert in shoreline stabilization , and Mr . Frederick Mushacke , Marine Resources Specialist I , employed by the Department' s Bureau of Marine Habitat Protection. At the conclusion of the hearing, the ALJ and representatives of the parties visited the Site . The record closed on December 5 , 1987 upon receipt of the stenographic record of the hearing. Position of the Applicant t Applicant contends that the permit should be granted to allow construction of a steel sheet piling wall across the entire Site to prevent the possibility of erosion to the bluff during unusual weather events such as hurricanes. Stone rip-rap to be installed along the toe of the wall would prevent erosion to the I Stony beach and to adjoining properties . The project should be undertaken now as a safeguard against future erosion of the bluff . The proposed Project would have no undue adverse impact upon tidal wetlands and generally complies with the standards for issuance of permits in areas adjacent to tidal wetlands ( 6 NYCRR Part 661 . 10 ( c ) , the Applicant argued. Position of Department Staff Department staff objects to the construction of the sheet steel wall and backfilling behind such wall , as activities which may impair and alter the natural condition of tidal wetlands . t - 3 - Department staff contends that the proposed Project is i unnecessary; that there is no evidence of erosion along the toe of the bluff; that the proposed structure would not protect the bluff from damage under extreme conditions but would prevent material from the bluff from nourishing the beach and would be likely to cause toe scour along the steel structure and erosion on neighboring parcels . The Project would be contrary. to the spirit and intent of the Tidal Wetlands Act and 6 NYCRR hart 661 , Department staff declared. V d 5 FINDINGS OF FACT $ 1 . Applicant is the owner of a parcel of land, 9 . 54 acres in area, situated on Long Island Sound in the Village of . Greetiport, `Town of Southold, Suffolk County, New York, as indicated upon Attachment 1 . 2 . New York State Tidal Wetlands Inventory Map No . 718-554 indicates the presence of tidal wetlands designated Littoral Zone I ( "LZ" ) along the Site. Inspection of the Site confirmed the presence of a band of Coastal Shoals, Bars and Flats ( "SM" ) in the intertidal zone . The area lying between the-Tine of Mean High Water and the crest of the seaward face of the bluff or cliff, is designated Adjacent Area ( "AA" ) . 3 . Applicant' s proposal to subdivide the Site into two lots , 5 acres and 4 . 54 acres in area, respectively, meets all of the requirements of the Tidal Wetlands Act and its implementing Land Use Regulations . The area of the proposed new logs would he well within the 40 , 000 square foot limitation contained in 6 NYCRR Part 661 . 6( a) ( 5 ) . 4 . Construction of a shoreline stabilization structure and the placement of fill in an Adjacent Area to tidal wetlands is a regulated activity and d'esignated in 6 NYCRR 661 . 5(b) ( 27 ) & ( 29 ) j as a "generally compatible use , permit required" ( "GCp" ) . The development restrictions contained in 6 NYCRR Part: 661 . 6 are not applicable to the proposed Project . 5 . The existing face of the bluff, which Applicant seeks to stabilize shows some minor erosion in two locations; the eastern end of the Site, and near the center of the Site. In both places , the erosion appears to have proceeded from the top and moved downward, indicating that ground water had exited through the face of the bluff or that surface water from above had percolated through the porous soil and then moved down the face of the bluff. There is no indication of erosion caused by storm-driven water and wind along the toe of the bluff . 6 . Applicant' s proposal to install approximately 912 linear feet of sheet steel retaining wall , armored at the toe with - 4 - rocks , if appropriate in the instant location, would also be an appropriate erosion control device for substantially the entire north shore of Suffolk County. It is not possible to predict with any reasonable degree of certainty the likelihood or frequency of the storm that would cause significant damage to the Site . Applicant has suggested, simply, that such a storm is possible . 7 . The top of the proposed steel wall would be at an elevation of approximately 9 feet above Mean Sea Level . The base flood elevation for the Site , which is in a velocity zone , is elevation 15 feet, which indicates that storm surges and waves could strike the bluff in an area 6 feet above the proposed bulkhead. Hence , the bulkhead would be minimally effective to protect the bluff face during such extreme storms . 8 . Some toe scour is visible along a bulkhead installed on the adjoining property, west of the proposed Project . Under extreme storm .conditions, . it .is likely that the Applicant' s proposed bulkhead would contribute to erosion of the stony beach and on adjoining properties, causing other owners to seek similar erosion control structures . 9 . Applicant' s Site includes a stony beach, strewn with boulders that provide significant protection from storm surges . The bluff, which is moderately vegetated, appears to be stable, except for the two previously discussed areas of erosion. i f CONCLUSIONS 1 . Applicant' s proposed lot-split meets the criteria of the Tidal Wetlands Act and regulations. 2 . The policy of the Tidal Wetlands Act is to preserve and protect tidal_ wetlands and to prevent their despoliation and destruction, giving due consideration to the reasonable economic and social development of the state (ECL 25-0102 ) . 3 . Although the Site has experienced no erosion damage from wind and storm tides, Applicant contends that such damage could be caused at some time in the future by a storm of unusual force ( a 50 year or 100 year storm) . That argument could be applied to the entire north shore of Long Island. - 5 - 4 . The erection of the proposed steel wall is not necessary for the reasonable development of Applicant' s Site into two large building lots , as he has proposed. If the houses are set back from the bluff a distance of at least 100 feet, it may never be necessary to build protective bulkheading. Reasonable protection of the bluff could be obtained by some careful regrading of the face , planting of protective vegetation and, perhaps , by the placement of rock rip-rap along the toe of the bluff . It is probable that such a soft approach would afford a greater degree of protection than would the proposed steel wall . 5 . The proposed retaining wall would cause disruption along the toe of the bluff as large rocks were removed to permit driving, of steel into the ground. Under high velocity storm conditions , the water could reach 6 feet above the proposed wall . Under storm conditions toe scour and erosion damage to adjoining properties is a probability. The record fails to establish a need for the proposed wall and , in addition, indicates that if erected, the wall would probably cause damage to the wetland area . RECOMMENDATIONS 1 . A permit should issue to the Applicant approving the proposed subdivision of the Site into two lots , as proposed. 2 . The proposal to build a steel retaining wall should be denied. 3 . Applicant should be encouraged to submit: a plan to Department Staff for approval , providing for regrading the face of the bluff in areas where erosion has occurred or where the angle of the face should be reduced. Such plan should also provide for planting of vegetation to hold and protect the face of the bluff . In addition, the plan may include placement of rock rip-rap along the toe of the bluff , as required, in the opinion of Department Staff. :. SvfFo%K Co. /4A66TAOI'l .) ^' s 1 i� / LVO CVv. MAP V6 / 3000 Lo T INL S i� r t - CO. 25 atw�t`w� 8 t JtoAt C-p L F �, �0 (V 0 . ZCL To P o F r✓1 a f O o c[ -0 J � fA- { ✓� J � � � � Fy V 0 0 �' o Sa ' pRo Po SAD /-1 00 , R o SAL- ��/oLA �►, q 9 L.o�v C� /S C n rc O .�o •.r O OATvH: M54- Ar Gacc -4100IZ7- SuFFoL. PuQf�o 5E: �oy /f MATTER OF SAL CAIOLA Attachment 1• State of New York DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING AND COMPLETE APPLICATION APPLICANT : Sal Caiola by En-Consultants , Inc . 1329 North Sea Road Southampton, NY 11968 APPLICATION NUMBER: 10-86-0647 PROJECT DESCRIPTION AND ?OCATION: Construct a sheet steel retaining wall along toe of bluff and on uphill side of road down face of bluff . A total of 962 + l . f . of retaining wall is proposed . For sections facing Long Island Sound stone armor will be placed . Approximately 400 cubic yards of clean sand and loam will be trucked in for backfill : Wall will be entirely above MHW. Create a 2 lot minor subdivision . Actual home construction will be landward of crest of bluff . Location : On Long Island Sound , Village of Greenport , Town of Southold , Suffolk County , NY. PERMITS APPLIED FOR : Tidal Wetlands SEQRA: The Board of Trustees , Town of Southold , as lead agency , determined that the magnitude of the environmental impact of the proposed project does not warrant the preparation of a Draft Environmental Impact Statement , and issued its determination on October 30 , 1986 , pursuant to 6 NYCRR Part 617 . PUBLIC HEARING: An adjudicatory public hearing on the application will be held on October 29 , 1987 , at 9 : 30 a.m. at the Southold Town Hall, 53095 Main Road , Southold, NY. This location is reasonably accessible to persons with a mobility impairment . 2 - STATUTORY AND REGULATORY PROVISIONS : The processing of this application is pursuant to Environmental Conservation Law ("ECL") Article 3 , Title 3 (General Functions) , Article 70 (Uniform Procedures) ; Article 25 (Tidal wetlands) ; Article 36 (Participation in Flood Insurance Program) ; and pursuant to the Official Compilation of Codes , Rules and Regulations of the State of New York ("6NYCRR") , Part 621 (Uniform Procedlures) and Part 661 (Tidal Wetlands--Land Use Regulations) ; and Part 624 (Permit Hearing Procedures) . FILING FOR PARTY STATUS : Party status to participate at the adjudicatory public hearing will be accorded to those persons who can provide a clear demonstration of social , economic, or environmental interests which are likely to be affected by the proposed project . All persons , groups , corporations or agencies desiring party status at the hearing must file a specific statement in writing containing precise grounds for opposition, support , or interest for the project , including the nature of the argument and evidence which the person intends to present at the hearing and any other matter believed relevant . REQUESTS FOR PART STATUS AT THE HEARING MUST BE RECEIVED AT THE OFFICE OF HEARINGS ON October 23 , 1987 . Such requests should be addressed to : Samuel J . Kearing , Jr . Administrative Law Judge NYSDEC Office of Hearings Building 40 , SUNY Stony Brook, New York 11794 Telephone: (516) 751-7900 , Extension 259 . DOCUMENT AVAILABILITY : The application can be reviewed and copies of reproducible portions obtained for 25-cents per page at the above address . All persons who have an interest in this proposed project are urged to attend the hearing , to be represented either individually or collectively and to submit pertinent testimony and exhibits to insure that all relevant issues are considered . The Decision of the Commissioner will be based solely upon the hearing record . 3 - Interpreter services shall be made available to deaf persons , at no charge , upon written request to the Administrative Law Judge within a reasonable time prior to the hearing pursuant to SAPA Section 202 ( 1) . The hearing may be cancelled if the filed objections are withdrawn or resolved . Samuel J. Kearing , Jr. Administrative Law Judge Stony Brook, New York DATE : September 11 , 1987 NEW YOR STATE DEPARTMENT'C 71RONMENTAL CONSERVATION REGULATE,_ .AFFAIRS .. �� ,��.r �T=��•T. D TO: ATE: • - _'r�. � RE'PLY==RE°-IJFRED BY �; FROM: ::. SUBJECT: �Jr(L =•:' !�'a Lt'.a_ ��- f�- C�C..y7 __..DATE`RETURNED- �^ _. ...... . .. S [ �l c •q . ._ -_- ._ --..REPLY;AT BOTTOM OF THIS FORM -._-- rye �j / �y t vk"CZ_l c .',.�. 6etKf f�+r.i ;WA-)f l'( cl ifoAl )� .4/4Q �- -1/1 � '/b� .� Fj� 'v' /'✓F�' ,r i �`�/�jt i.9 :%' Gi i.�J oCt/; r�.�+har. Vic• .�!' N� ��f+oa.' n 4 I.s CV r •4'. ��• iJ ? �`/"�� `L, �1 /, -��/>/:j..j fprl4+�-� n/— �2..aI";!�►��' j9i,�.V 47/ � �:� ir.�w_ /r�C Cid f r� �`!` � rn-� �/t '� �'cl/ /,�i�••�,'� Jlr ��, Z g:�-�— IC, -EZ_ Vo (4-iD d� 6,c-� (,�1. � ram✓ �-o, .Q� , v - HENRY P. SMITH, President TELEPHONE JOHN M. BREDEMEYER, Vice-Pres. C= (516) 765-1892 PHILLIP J. GOUBEAUD �. ALBERT KRUPSKI, JR. ELLEN M. LARSEN ��1 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF.SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 February 4, 1987 Mr. Roy L. HAje, President En-Consultants, Inc. 1329 North Sea Road Southampton, New York 11968 Re: Sal CA ola - Wetland Application No. 400 Dear Mr. Haje: The following action was taken by the Trustees during their regular meeting held on January 29, 1987 regarding the above referenced matter. RESOLVED that the Southold Town Trustees TABLE the Wetland Application No. 400 submitted by En-Consultants, Inc. , on behalf of Sal Caiola .until a copy of his D.E.C. Permit is received. Should you have any questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to contact this office at the telephone number listed above. Very truly yours, Henry P. Smi'th, President Board of Town-Trustees HPS:ip cc: Clifford C. Wray, Jr. , Deputy Regional Permit Admin. , D.E.C. , Stony Brook New".York�State Department of Environmenta Monservatron . Regulatory, Affairs Unit..•.- - - --: Bldg. 40, SUNY, Rm...'219.: . _._ ... . . Stony Brook; NY 11794 .:- - (516) 751-7900 Henry G.Will Commissioner January 27, 1987 Mr. Henry P. Smith, President ' Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall , P.O. Box 728 Southold, NY 11P71 Re: Sal Caiola, NYSDEC Tidal Wetlands Application No. 10-86-0647 Dear Mr. Smith: This letter is in response to your letter to us of January 15,' 1987 requesting our comments. and recommendations on the above referenced application. The Department has an objection to the project for the following reasons: 1. The bluff in the project area -is vegetated and appears to be relatively stable with no significant erosion problems. 2. The impacts of the proposed project include loss of beach in front of proposed retaining wall , possible scouring impacts on neighboring properties, destablization of the bluff caused by disturbance to the bluff; and possible increased potential for further subdivision and development closer to the bluff- than would be environmentally sound: - - - - The Department recommends that the applicant consider alternatives to placement of the proposed retaining wall through maintenance and enhancement of the existing vegetative cover using small canopy vegetation (grasses) and fertilizers. Maintaining a substantial distance from. the crest of the bluff to any proposed development will allow this area to recede naturally and will allow, if necessary in -the future, further bluff stabiIization(such as regrading top of bluff to 3:1 slope or- better with re- vegetation.). If you have any questions concerning our objections to this proposed project, please contact me at (516) 751-7900, extension 349. Very truly yours, 01 (?, k"r'k Clifford C. Wray, Or. Deputy Regional Permit Administrator C� R.L. . c Haje J. n C. Hamilton G1R )NNIENTAL SERVICES EN-CONSULTANTS, INC . 1329 NORTH SEA ROAD, SOUTHAMPTON, NEW YORK 11968 516-283-6360 February 4, 1987 Mr.-.Clifford Wray, Jr. New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Building, SUNY Stony Brook, New York 11794 Re: Sal Caiola 10-86-0647 Dear Mr. Wray: I would like to comment on your January 27, 1987 letter to the Southold Board of Trustees, a copy of which was sent to me. This project has been designed based upon sound environ- mental considerations and past policies and recommendations of the New York State Department of Environmental Con- servation. Specifically, the structure is significantly landward of the line of MEW. The vertical bulkhead will be armored with stone rip-rap to minimize or prevent the possibility of toe scour and effects upon adjacent properties. While much of the bluff is presently vegetated, other areas do display erosion. Rather than wait for the situation to deteriorate further, we believe it is prudent to construct this project at the present time. Following its construction and placement of back- fill, the area will be heavily vegetated to stabilize. We see no correlation between the shoreline stabilization project and development of the upland. The latter must -2- meet all applicable zoning requirements and setbacks from the crest of the bluff. We are dismayed that the DEC has again apparently modified its position on shoreline stabilization structures. Formerly, vertical walls with rip-rap protection were approved in a pro forma manner. This was done as the structures were shown to have no adverse effect upon adjacent properties or the beach in front. Placement well landward of MHW is a further mitigation technique. We know of no recent studies which show that a project of this type will now have any adverse effects. We, therefore, urge you and the Southold Trustees to approve the project as applied for. Yours truly, Roy L. Haj e President RLH:p cc: v8outhold Trustees Sal Caiola HENRY P. SMITH, President ,; �G JOHN M. BREDEMEYER, Vice-Pres. to TELEPHONE (516) 765-1892 PHILLIP J. GOUBEAUD ALBERT KRUPSKI, JR. . ' ELLEN M. LARSEN BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 February 4, 1987 Mr. Roy L. Haje, President En-Consultants, Inc. 1329 North Sea Road Southampton, New York 11968 Re: Sal Caola - Wetland Application No. 400 Dear Mr. Haje: The following action was taken by the Trustees during their regular meeting held on January 29, 1987 regarding the above referenced matter. RESOLVED that the Southold Town Trustees TABLE the Wetland Application No. 400 submitted by En-Consultants, Inc. , on behalf of Sal Caiola until a copy of his D.E.C. Permit is received. Should you have any questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to contact this office at the telephone number listed above. Very truly yours, 1'04YYL� Henry P. Smith, President Board of Town.-Trustees HPS:ip cc: Clifford C. Wray, Jr. , Deputy Regional Permit Admin. , D.E.C. , Stony Brook ��Nevq York State Department of Environmental Conservationegulatory Affairs Unit .....,, Bldg. 40, SUNY, Rm. 219 Stony Brook, NY 11794 (516) 751-7900 Henry G.Williams Commissioner January 27, 1987 Mr. Henry P. Smith, President Board of Town Trustees Town of Southold Town Hall , P.O. Box 728 Southold, NY 11971 Re: Sal Caiola, NYSDEC Tidal Wetlands Application No. 10-86-0647 Dear Mr. Smith: This letter is in response to your letter to us of January 15, 1987 requesting our comments and recommendations on the above referenced application. The Department has an objection to the project for the following reasons: 1. The bluff in the project area is vegetated and appears to be relatively stable with no significant erosion problems. 2. The impacts of the proposed project include loss of beach in front of proposed retaining wall , possible scouring impacts on neighboring properties, destablization of the bluff caused by disturbance to the bluff, and possible increased potential for further subdivision and development closer to the bluff than would be environmentally sound. The Department recommends that the applicant consider alternatives to placement of the proposed retaining wall through maintenance and enhancement of the existing vegetative cover using small canopy vegetation (grasses) and fertilizers. Maintaining a substantial distance from the crest of the bluff to any proposed development will allow this area to recede naturally and will allow, if necessary in the future, further bluff stabiiization(such as regrading top of bluff to 3:1 slope or better with re- vegetation.) . If you have any questions concerning our o55ections to this proposed project, p1dase contact me at (516) 751-7900, extension 349. Very truly yours , 0J. , , Clifford C. Wray, Or. Deputy Regional Permit Administrator CCW:jf cc: R.L. Haje J. Gilman C. Hamilton HENRY P. SMITH, President . x JOHN M. BREDEMEYER, Vice-Pres. ® z ,��,. TELEPHONE ONE J. GOUBEAUD � ` ' @ (516) 765-1892 ALBERT KRUPSKI, JR. ELLEN M. LARSEN �,� � BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 January 15, 1987 Mr. Robert Thurber New York State D.E.C. Bldg. 40, SUNY - Rm. 219 Stony Brook, New York 11794 , Re: Sal Caiola Wetland Application No. 400 Dear Mr. Thurber: May we'have your comments and recommendations on the above referenced application by January 27, 1987. Very truly yours, �r Henry P. Smith, President Board of Town Trustees HPS:ip Board of Trustees - Page 17. December 23, 1986 14. SAL CAIOLA - APPLICATION NO. 400 - TABLED Moved by Trustee Bredemeyer seconded by Trustee Goubeaud it was RESOLVED that the Southold Town Trustees TABLE the Wetland Application No. 400 submitted by En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of Sal Caiola pending coordination with the New York State D.E.C. for approval. 14. Vote of Board: Ayes: All This resolution was declared duly adopted. 15. OLOF NELSON - APPLICATION NO. 467 - TABLED Moved by Trustee Bredemeyer seconded by Trustee Goubeaud it was RESOLVED to TABLE the Wetland Application No 467 submitted by En-Consultants Inc. on behalf of Olof Nelson pending a field inspection by the Board of Trustees. 15. Vote of Board: Ayes: All This resolution was declared duly adopted. Dr. Martin Carrell requested that the Secretary strike the comments previously submitted to the Trustees regarding this application Dr. Garrell stated that the Conservation Advisory Council will have to-re inspect this proposal and transmit a new recommendation on same. President Smith advised that he received a telephone call from a Mr. Anderson who was quite upset. Mr. Anderson purchased a mooring in West Harbor on Fishers Island and was advised by the Harbormaster, Mr. John Clavin, that he only purchased the instrument and not the permit. Trustee Smith advised Mr. Anderson that he would have to go to Judge Raymond Edwards or the Southold Town Board if he has a problem with this matter. 16. ROBERT E. JOHNSON - LEAD AGENCY DECLARATION - APPLICATION NO. 474 Moved by Trustee Goubeaud seconded by Trustee Bredemeyer it was RESOLVED that the Southold Town Trustees declare itself lead agency in regard to the State Environmental Quality Review Act in the matter of the application of Robert E. Johnson for a Wetland Permit on certain property located at 430 Koke Drive and Corey Creek Road, Southold. 16. Vote of Board: Ayes: All This resolution was declared duly adopted. 17. ROBERT E. JOHNSON - LEAD AGENCY DECLARATION - APPLICATION NO. 485 Moved by Trustee Smith seconded by Trustee Bredemeyer it was RESOLVED that the Southold Town Trustees declare itself lead agency in regard to the State Environmental Quality Review Act in the matter of the application of Robert E. & Eileen M. Johnson for a Wetland Permit on certain property located at 430 Koke Drive and Corey Creek Road, Southold. 17. Vote of Board: Ayes: All This resolution was declared duly adopted. The Board declared lead agency at this time to get the permit process in motion and after the next field inspection the Trustees can proceed with the request for the waiver in regard to this construction. Board of Trustees - Page 18. December 23, 1986 A recess was called at 9:00 P.M. and the regular meeting resumed at 9:10 P.M. 18. ROY L. HAJE, PRESIDENT, EN-CONSULTANTS, INC. ON BEHALF OF KEARNSPORT, LTD. .PERMIT EXTENSION REQUEST. Moved by Trustee Krupski.seconded by Trustee Larsen it was RESOLVED to APPROVE the request made by En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of KEARNSPORT, LTD. for an extension on permit no. 1954 and 207 for a period of six months. Said permits will expire on June 23, 1987. 18. Vote of Board: Ayes: All This resolution was declared duly adopted. 19. PAUL FERDENZI - LEAD AGENCY DECLARATION Moved by Trustee Larsen seconded by Trustee Krupski it was RESOLVED that the Southold Town Trustees declare itself lead agency in regard to the State Environmental Quality Review Act in the matter of the application of Paul Ferdenzi for a Wetland Permit on certain property located at 470 Haywaters Drive, Cutchouge. 19. Vote of Board: Ayes: All This resolution was declared duly adopted. 20. MURRAY KLAPPER - PERMIT EXTENSION REQUEST. Moved by Trustee Bredemeyer seconded by Trustee Krupski it was RESOLVED to APPROVE the request made by En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of Murray Klapper for an extension on permit no 226. Said permit will expire on June 23, 1987. 20. Vote of Board: Ayes: All This resolution was declared duly adopted. 21. ANNA PARLAMIS - LEAD AGENCY DECLARATION Moved by Trustee Goubeaud seconded by Trustee Krupski it was RESOLVED that the Southold Town Trustees declare itself lead agency in regard to the State Environmental Quality Review Act in the matter of the application of Anna Parlamis for a Wetland Permit on certain property located at 663A Bayshore Road, Greenport. 21. Vote of Board: Ayes: All This resolution was declared duly adopted. 22. This resolution was done earlier in the meeting. See page 14. Elizabeth Yaro. 23. SALT LAKE ASSOCIATION., INC. - LEAD AGENCY DECLARATION Moved by Trustee Krupski seconded by Trustee Bredemeyer it was RESOLVED that the Southold Town Trustees declare itself-_head agency in regard to the State Environmental Quality Review Act in the matter of the application of the Salt Lake Association, Inc. HENRY P. SMITH, President ; :L JOHN M. BREDEMEYER, Vice-Pres. o TELEPHONE PHILLIP J. GOUBEAUD (516) 765-1892 ,so ALBERT KRUPSKI, JR. ELLEN M. LARSEN �� BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 DECEMBER 23, 1986 7:00 P.M. - Regular Meeting The regular meeting of the Board of Town Trustees was held on December 23, 1986 at the Town Hall, Main Road, Southold. The meeting was called to order by President Henry P. Smith at 7:00 P.M. . - Present were: President Henry P. Smith Vice President John M. Bredemeyer, III Trustee Phillip J. Goubeaud Trustee Albert Krupski, Jr. Bay Constable Donald Dzenkowski Secretary Ilene Pfifferling Trustee Ellen M. Larsen (7:10 P�M.) Trustee Smith advised that the date for the January field inspections will be held on January 22, 1987. Trustees are to depart from Town Hall at 12:00 P.M. . The date for the next regular meeting will be held on January 29, 1987 to commence at 7:00 P.M. . Moved by Trustee Bredemeyer seconded by Trustee Goubeaud it was RESOLVED to APPROVE the minutes of the November 25, 1986 meeting as corrected: Communication No. 10 - the word marshes is to read water. Vote of Board: Ayes: Trustees Smith, Bredemeyer, Goubeaud and Krupski-Absent: Larsen This resolution was declared duly adopted. Moved by Trustee Bredemeyer seconded by Trustee Krupski it was RESOLVED to RESCIND the following resolutions adopted on November 25, 1986 on page 23 as follows: D - SAL CAIOLA - WETLAND APPLICATION NO. 450 - TABLED Moved by Trustee Goubeaud seconded by Trustee Larsen it was RESOLVED to Deny the wetland application of Sal Caiola whereas there is no evidence of undermining of the lateral support of land in the vicinity based on land west of this property there has been no erosion. Vote of Board: Trustee Krupski Nay, Trustee Smith, Nay, Trustee Bredemeyer, Nay Trustee Goubeaud: Aye Trustee Larsen Ay? D.- Moved by Trustee Bredemeyer seconded by Trustee Smith it was RESOLVED to APPROVE the wetland application of Sal Caiola to construct a steel retaining wall along the tow of bluff. A total of 962t lin. ft. of retaining Board of Trustees - Page 2 December 23, , 1986 wall is proposed. For sections facing Long Island Sound stone armor will be placed. Approximately 400 cu. yds. of clean sand and loam will be trucked in for backfill. Wall will be entirely above MHW. Property is located on Sound Drive, Greenport. Vote of Board: Ayes: Trustee Smith, Trustee Bredemeyer Nay: Trustee Larsen Abstain: Trustee Krupski, Trustee Goubeaud This resolution was declared duly lost. Vote of Board to RESCIND: Ayes: Trustees Smith, Trustee Bredemeyer, Trustee Goubeaud, Trustee Krupski: Absent: Trustee Larsen This resolution was declared duly adopted. Trustee Larsen arrived at 7:10 P.M. Trustee Smith reported that he received a telephone call from Mr. Herbert L. Ortner, Attorney who represents Mr. & Mrs. Richard Prieto regarding a question of a right- of way on Corey Creek, Southold,. Trustee Smith reiterated that in his opinion this property is a R.O.W. unless this can be proven differently and if any of the mooring renewals come up at that road ending that they will be approved. Moved by Trustee Smith seconded by Trustee Larsen it was RESOLVED to APPROVE the renewal of mooring permits at the end of the R.O.W. on Corey Creek, Southold. Vote of Board: Ayes: All This resolution was declared duly •adopted. Moved by Trustee Smith seconded by Trustee Larsen it was RESOLVED to APPROVE the FEBRUARY 1987 Mooring renewals. Vote of Board: Ayes: All This resolution was declared duly adopted. Trustee Smith gave the Trustees report for November 1986 as follows: Application Fees $75.00, Wetland Applications $700.00, Wetland Inspections $40.00, Docks and Bulkhead Fees $130.50 and Mooring Renewal Fees $45.00 for a total of $990.50. This has been turned over to the Supervisor to be placed in the General Fund. II. Public Notices: Trustee Smith advised that these notices are put on the Town Clerk's bulletin board if anyone wishes to review them. The President proceeded with agenda item number III. Communications. III. Communications: 1A. Mr. John Wickham appeared before the Board to discuss repair work needed on his dike. The Board determined that an application is necessary for this work and requested Mr. Wickham to submit same to the Trustee office. Moved by Trustee Smith seconded by Trustee Bredemeyer it was RESOLVED that Mr. John Wickham is to submit an application to the Board of Trustees for work to be done on the dike located on Grathwohl Road, New HENRY P. SMITH, President TELEPHONE JOHN M. BREDEMEYER, Vice-Press o .r � (516) 765-1892 PHILLIP J. GOUBEAUD ,As • ALBERT KRUPSKI, JR. ELLEN M. LARSEN BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 December 24, 1986 Mr. Roy L. Haje, Pres. En-Consultants, Inc. . 1329 North Sea Road Southampton, N. Y. 11968 RE: Sal Caiola Wetland Application No. 400 Dear Mr. Haje: Please be advised that the- Board of Trustees TABLED the wetland application for the above referenced project pending recommendations from the Conservation Advisory Council. Very truly yours, 0- Henry P. Smith, Pres. Board of Town Trustees HPS:ao ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES d� EN-CONSULTANTS,. INC . 1329 NORTH SEA ROAD, SOUTHAMPTON, NEW YORK 11968 516-283-6360 December .l, 1986 Southold Trustees Town of Southold Post Office Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 Re: Sal Caiola Dear Sirs and Madam: Please be advised that we contemplate no jetty work on the project referenced above. Work will consist of a revetment along the toe of the . slope only. Thank you for your attention. Your truly, Ro Haj e President . =:p cc: Sal Caiola James H. Rambo.; Inc. HENRY P. SMITH, President ' s a JOHN M. BREDEMEYER, Vice-Pres. TELEPHONE o ,��,, i � � PHILLIP J. GOUBEAUD ` ��� F� (516) 765-1892 ALBERT KRUPSKI, JR. ELLEN M. LARSEN '�.� BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 December 2, 1986 Mr. Roy L. Haje, President En-Consultants, Inc. 1329 North Sea Road Southampton, New York 11968 Re: Sal Caiola Wetland Application No. 400 Dear Mr. Haje: Please 'be advised that the Board of Trustees have Tabled. the determination on the above referenced application. The Board will make a determination at the next regular meeting to be held on December 23, 1986• Very truly yours, J Henry P. Smith, President Board of Town Trustees HPS:ip cc: file LEGAL NOTICE 1 NOTICE.OFtHEARING- ON WETLAND COUNTY OF S U F FO L K ' S �7NOTICE IS HEREBY GIV STATE OF NEW YORK ss EN THAT PUBLIC HEAR- •. INGS WILL BE HELD BY ;;THE TOWN TRUSTEES'OF TOWN OF SOUTHOLD, Patricia Wood, being duly sworn, says that she is the i;,`;.AT THE SOUTHOLD TOWN Editor, of THE LONG ISLAND TRAVELER-WATCHMAN HALL, MAIN ROAD ,, SOUTHOLD, NEW YORK, a public newspaper printed at Southold, in Suffolk County; ON TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 25. 1986, ON THE FOLLOW and that the notice of which the annexed is a printed copy, .;;,,.. has been published in said Lon Island Traveler-Watchman sa�n;�ING -APPLICATIONS;;,FOR.. . P g / / ,,;`?ERMITS UNDER THE;PRO-; once each week for . weeks VISIONS OF s. = HEi _ WETLAND ORDINANCE OF i .s,,THE TOWN OFSOUTHOLD:F successively, commencing on the 7:30 P.M:IN THE MATTER' j OF THE APPLICATION OF day , 19 � .., JOSEPH A. BAR— to in Y stall two separate low profle jet ties at the approximate existing ' length of 30'at`mean high lvater . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . level. Property is located �on :West Lake Drive, Southold.: 7.32 P M.IN THE-MATTA; OF THE APPLICATION.`'W' CT' STEPHEN EICH to construct . Sworn to before me this . . . . . . . . /. . . . . . . . . . . day of a 40' X 3%z'_catwalk with,s 6,' X 18' floating dock on_fir- ;.shamomaque Pond.•Property is - . . . , . , 19 - ' located on Ruch----La-ne,•^. Southold. 1:34 P.M:IN THE MATTER r OF THE APPLICATION OF & D REALT-Y C/O CLIF- FORD CORNELL to construct a single family dwelling anc.,tq 1 Notary Public ,.gxcavate approximately 400 cu 3 ydsd of, material, Mattituck BAR.BAR.A FORBES ••A&� `elc Property is located on Plotary Pub'1;3, State of New York Cox Neck Road, Mattituek; No. 430E9'8 7:36 P.M:IN THE MATTER Qualified in Suffolk County OF THE APPLfC-A 'd OF Commission Expires�z�_ ,3/. 19 06e ENI CONSHLTAI`' ,-1NC:,ON _ BEHALF OF SAL CAIOLA to ".,.—construct a steel retaining wall c .:along the tow'of'bluff and on ,-,'uphill side of the road down the face of the bluff: A.total of 962± lin.ft.of retaining wall is proposed. For sections facing Long Island Sound stone armor ; will be place.Approximately 400 cu.yds. of clean sand and loam ' will be trucked in for backfill. Wall will be entirely above MHW. Project is located on Long Island Sound, Sound `Drive, Greenport. ALL PERSONS IN- TERESTED IN SAID MAT- TERS SHOULD APPEAR AT THE TIME AND PLACE ABOVE SPECIFIED AND WILL BE GIVEN AN bP PORTUNIT'Y TO BE HEARD. COMMENTS MAY BE SUB- MITTED IN WRITING PRIOR TO THE DATE OF THE HEARING. F' Henry` P. Smiih, President Board of Town Trustees DATE: November 10, 1986 1T 1 1/19/O//O\ • i 3 ;'LEGAL NOTI`CE r 'PN ,NOTICE OF HEARING ON WETLAND APPLICATIONS I."-­~NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN F � THAT ,.PUBLIC HEARINGS " WILL BE.:HELD=IjY THE STATE OF NEW YORK ) ;TOWN ..,TRUSTEES .00, IIE ) SS' TOWN OF SOUTH[�LD;.ti C SOUTHOLD'. � TO OUNTY OF SUFFOLK ) . THE e" WN, ,,ra I �HALR�MAIN ROAD;S(?UTI»� h:OLD,'NEW YQRK,:ONTUES '{, Carol Sgarlat-a of Greenport, in DAY 2b,.`198B THE FOLD o ' "s•r LOWING APPLIdOiONSVOW said County,being duly sworn,says that he/she is PERMITS=UNDER A HE`PRO- t-:y�yISIONS OF THE>WETLIND Principal Clerk of THE SUFFOLK TIMES,a Weekly LO,RDINANCE OF�THEyTOWN Newspaper, published at Greenport, in the Town �,W SOUTHOLD � 7:30 'P.M:-IN THE -MAT of Southold, County of Suffolk and State of New TER OF THE APPLICATION OF JOSEPH A BARBATO to York, and that the Notice of which the annexed is install t `to' eparal low pi`ofile a printed copy, has been regularly published In betties of the approximate exist One u sing Ieiigtli',6f 30 at' mean high said Newspaper once each week for watec'height.-Property;.-is weeks successively, commencing on the 13 Gated on West Lake, Dnve, #xMKyrM, .�r a day of 19—$b i Southold i ,�lttct ,� r tN Nnvnmhor 7:32 ..P,M"IN TjE1 4, _,'_TER OF THE APj'X:ICA�TION 'OF STEPHEN.FICH O',,con 'a struct 40'z 31/2'cafwalk with a $r j 6' is;:18, floating' Oock on.'Az `snamomaque Pond,Property is.... 41p lark .located on Itii&i Lane;South r + old. 7:34 P M IN THE MAT Sworn to befor this TER'OF THE APPLICATION .,; OF.C,&D REALTY C/O CLIF 19 BY of FORD CORNELL fo construct MARY K.DEGNAN .single family dwelling and to r �//l(�.('� CRY PUBLIC,State of New YOT excavate approximately 400 cu �' Suffolk County No 48,%".1 yda. 3of inatenalF �Mattituck'' is ocated on Term Expires Februar a?I ..<Creek.-Property ' ' Cox Neck Road,Mattituck. 7:36 P.M.IN--THE MAT= _ _> TER OF THE APPLICATION,-; ...OF EN-CONSULTANTS,INC. ON..:r,BEHAL CAIO "e-OF.':: LA to construct'a step r taming wall'along`';the: tow "bluff and on side ofthe F; road down the.-face of.the bluff jk.total of 962 `of retain x',> ing wall is proposed.For sections ;_+y - facing Long Island Sound stone _armor,.-will be placed..Approxi- _-- - i'mately 400 cu.yds.of clean sand _ -and loam will be.trucked-in for backfill. Wall wi11 be entirely above MHW.Project is located on Long Island Sound,Sound Drive,Greenport. . t ALL.:.......PERSONS-,, ,`-.IN TERESTED--IN -`SAID MAT= i TERS SHOULD APPEAR AT THE .TIME -,AND PLACE ABOVE SPECIFIED -AND WILL BE GIVEN AN OPPOR- TUNITY TO BE HEARD.COM- ._`. MENTS MAY BE SUBMITTED ' IN WRITING PRIOR TO THE DATE OF THE HEARING. ::.:Henry P.Smith,President Board of Town Trustees 1lU '3 ggpT ej�g�T19,ss HENRY P. SMITH, President o f ,k JOHN M. BREDEMEYER, Vice-Pres. 6� TELEPHONE (516) 765 1892 PHILLIP J. GOUBEAUD 7 ALBERT KRUPSKI, JR. ELLEN M. LARSEN BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 - Southold, New York 11971 November 6, 1986 Mr. Roy L. Haje, President En-Consultants, Inc. 1329 North Sea Road Southampton, New York 11968 Re: Sal Caiola Wetland Application No. 400 Dear Mr. Haje: The following action was taken by the Board of Trustees at their regular meeting held on October 30, 1986 after visiting the site with you and Dr. Samuels and discussing the entire application and future plans for the site. RESOLVED that the Board of Town Trustees RESCIND the Significant Environmental Declaration Declared on the wetland application no. 400 submitted by En- Consultants, Inc. on behalf of Sal Caiola for a wetland permit on property located on Sound Drive, Greenport. Very truly yours, Henry P. Smith, President Board of Town Trustees HPS:ip HENRY P. SMITH President �h uP ws r •' TELEPHONE JOHN M. BREDEMEYER, Vice-Pres. ti".. PHILLIP J. GOUBEAUD � (516) 765-1892 41, ALBERT KRUPSKI, JR. ELLEN M. LARSEN BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 - Southold, New York 11971 S.E.Q.R.A. NEGATIVE DECLARATION NOTICE OF NO SIGNIFICANT EFFECT ON THE ENVIRONMENT NAME: EN-CONSULTANTS, INC. FOR SAL CAIOLA APPLICATION NO. 400 Date: October 30, 1986 This notice is issued pursuant to the provisions of Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law State Environmental Quality Review and 6NYCRR Part 617, Section 617.10 and Chapter 44 of the Code of the Town of Southold, notice is hereby given that the Southold Town Trustees, as lead agency for the action described below has determined that the project will not have a significant effect on the environment. Please take further notice that this declaration should not be considered a determination made for any other department or agency which may also have an application pending for the same or similar project. TYPE OF ACTION: TYPE II DESCRIPTION OF ACTION:Appellant proposes to construct a steel retaining wall along the tow of bluff and on uphill side of the road down the face of the bluff. A total of 962± lin. ft.of retaining wall is proposed. For sections facing Long Island Sound stone armor will be placed. Approximately 400 cu. yds. of clean sand and loam will be trucked in for backfill. Wall will be entirely above MHW. LOCATION OF PROJECT:Sound Drive, Greenport REASONS SUPPORTING THIS DETERMINATION: 1. An environmental assessment form has been submitted which indicated that there would be no adverse effect to the environment should the project be implemented as planned. 2. Because there has been no response in the allotted time from the Southold Town Building Dept. and the New York State D.E.C. it is assumed that there are no objections nor comments from those agencies. Page 2. Sal Caiola Further information regarding this application can be obtained by contacting Mr. Henry P. Smith, President, Board of Town Trustees, Southold Town Hall, Main Road, Southold or by calling (516) 765-1892. cc: Robert A. Greene, D.E.C. , Stony Brook Commissioner Henry G. Williams, D.E.C. , Albany Stephen Mars, Army Corps of Engineers Thomas Hart, Coastal Management Conservation Advisory Council Bldg. Dept. Board of Appeals File Town Clerk's Bulletin Board En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of Sal Caiola MEMO FOR YOUR INFORMATION: RE: Sal Caiola Please be advised that Mr. Robert Thurber called today from the D.E.C. and said that he has spoken to Mr. Gillman of the D.E.C. , who thought that the Trustees should have an overall project plan in making a determination under S.E.Q.R.A. 10-29-86 HENRY P. SMITH, President {" TELEPHONE JOHN M. BREDEMEYER, Vice-Pres. PHILLIP J. GOUBEAUD (516) 765-1892 A ^'T ALBERT KRUPSKI, JR. ELLEN M. LARSEN BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 October 1, 1986 Mr. Robert Thurber Senior Environmental Analyst New York State Dept. of Environmental Conservation Bldg. 40, SUNY, Room 219 Stony Brook, New York 11794 RE: 10-86-0647 - Sal Caiola Dear Mr. Thurber: At the request of Mr. Roy L. Haje, agent for Mr. Sal Caiola, we have been requested to arrange a meeting with you at the subject property to review this proposal. Will you be available to meet at the Southold Town Hall, Trustee Office, located on Main Road, Southold on October 23, 1986 at 3:00 P.M.? We would appreciate confirmation of your attendance by calling this office at 765-1892. Thank you for your cooperation in this matter. We await your response. Very truly yours, Henry P. Smith, President �Boaa�rd�r of Town Trustees- A . Ilene Pfifferling, WClerk HPS:ip cc: Roy L. Haje Sal Caiola 1 HENRY P. SMITH, President { �G TELEPHONE JOHN M. BREDEMEYER, Vice-Pres. C=3 (516) 765-1892 PHILLIP J. GOUBEAUD ALBERT KRUPSKI, JR. ELLEN M. LARSEN BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 September 12, 1986 Mr. Roy L. Haje En-Consultants, Inc. 1329 North Sea Road Southampton, N. Y. 11968 RE: Sal Caiola Wetland Application #400 Dear Mr. Haje; Please be advised, we are in receipt of your letter of September 5,' 1986 regarding the above application. Your - letter has bee placed on the September 25th, 1986 Agenda under Communication # ,II. If you wish to attend the meeting the Board will hear your concerns. If you have any questions please do not hesitate to contact this office. Very truly yours, enry . Smith,Pres. Board of Town Trustees HPS:ao ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES A4 EN-CONSULTANTS, INC . 1329 NORTH SEA ROAD, SOUTHAMPTON, NEW YORK 11968 516-283-6360 September 5, 1986 Southold Trustees Town of Southold Post Office Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 Re: Sal Caiola Wetland Application #400 Dear Sirs: I am in receipt of your positive declaration requiring preparation of a DEIS. Except for the length of the project, it does not differ from several others which were approved by your Board. We are, therefore, puzzled by the necessity of a DEIS and would like the opportunity to meet with the Board to discuss the matter further. Would you please notify me when I may appear. Yo try ply, G' . RoHaje President RLH:p cc: Sal Caiola Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 1179 TELEPHONE _ Southold, New York 11971 (516)765-1801 SOUTHOLD TOWN CONSERVATION ADVISORY COUNCIL July 28, 1986 To: Southold Town Trustees From: Southold Town CAC Re: Applications reviewed by CAC at the regular meeting held July 22, 1986 No . 398 - Harold Wilsberg - Recommend disapproval - The Council would like the applicant to either resubmit or .amend the application for only a floating dock and no bulk- head. The Council recommends the floating dock instead of the bulkhead to allow for the extensive colonization of spartina which would stabilize the land and reduce the need for any bulkhead. No. 400 - Sal Caiola_..'= Recomm.end---dis'ap'proyal .- Th.e Council feels it is a naural shoreline with no other bulkheads adjacent to the property and the structure could cause erosion of the adjacent beaches . The Council suggests the applicant plant natural vegetation instead. No . 402 - Gerald Rupp 'Recommend disapproval The Council disapproves because the slope is in good condition and is holding as is . If the applicant does anything further it could disturb the natural vegetation which would lead to serious erosion problems. mp The Council does recommend the repair of the stairs and existing bulkhead. They suggest the applicant either amend or resubmit the applicatic to do the repairs suggested and placing a small deck at the base of the stairs but proposing no retaining walls . No. 319_ - Ted Dowd - The Council feels a full EIS is neccessary. Significant Type I action. It should be' discussed publicl} . and allow imput from interested parties at the hearing. No . 388 - Leonard Schlegal - Recommend :approval"with stipulations . Page 2 The applicant must recognize the sensitivity of the area. There should be minimal clearing during construction; no lawns on the wetland side of the house (area between house and marsh) ; plant appropriate vegetation on wetlands side of house; and insure nutrient flow (f.rom' fertilizers , etc. ) into the creek be minimal. No . 394 - Frank R. Reilly - Recommend approval with stipulations . The cabin and retaining walls are approved. - The ramp and dock are de- pendent upon neighbors approval for . access. If the path is to cross wetland the Council does not approve . No. 403 - John Becht - Recommend approval provided the applicant follows the plans as sketched with elevation over the spartina No. 4G4 - Goldsmith' s Boat Shop - Recommend"approval. No. 405 - Mark Baxter - Recommend a:p*proval: wi'th stipulations . 1 . All drainage must be on property. 2. Minimal clearing of vegetation. 3. Plant 10 ' of vegetation on wetland side of house, no lawn! No. 406 - Richard Anderson - Recomm.end 'approval. No . 407 - Arnold Blair —Recommend approval but keep the retaining wall in a straight line. No. 408 - The Nature Conservancy = Tabl'ed. No. 409 - Douglas Miller - Tabled. The Council is to request additional info from applicant, But, at this time does feel it will need an EIS , Type I No. 410 - Sal R. Varano - Recommend approval with' stipulation. Replace bulkhead in place , do not move out as shown in plans . No. .411 John Morse - Recommend approval . No. 412 Nicholas J . Cutron - Recommend dis'aPproval. No need for bulkhead the slope is vegetated, there is no erosion, it is not subject to extreme storm conditions and there are no other bulkheads to either side. No . 413 - Douglas Moore - Recommend approval . No. 414 - C & L Realty - Reco.mmend approval. I a-` f New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Bldg 40, SUNY Campus, Rm21.9 Stony Brook, N.Y. 11794 Henry P. Smith,Pres . July 21, 1986 Southold Town Board of Trustees Town Hall, 53095 Main Rd. Southold, N.Y. 3+"1 Re: LEAD AGENCY COORDINATION RESPONSE Sal Caiola (Southold Trustees No.400) Dear Mr. Smith: This letter responds to your communication of J4AV_27, 1986 regarding lead agency coordination for the above-noted project, under Article 8 (State Environmental Quality Review - SEQR) of the Environmental Conservation Law and 6 NYCRR Part 617. The Department has the following interest in this project: DEC Permits (if any) : Tidal Wetlands needed DEC Contact Person: Robert N. Thurber SEQR Classification: [X] Type I [ ] Unlisted (as per your determination) DEC Position: Based on the information provided: [X] DEC has no objection to your agency assuming lead agency status for this action. [ ] DEC wishes to assume lead agency status for this action. [ ] DEC needs additional information in order to respond (see comments) . [ ] DEC cannot be lead agency because it has no jurisdiction in this action. Comments: [ ad see attached [ ] none at this time. Comments may be provide at a later date when clarified plans are reattwmd received do reviewed. If you do not concur with the DEC position indicated above, please contact this office to resolve designation of lead agency within the time allowable under Part 617. Please feel free to contact this office for further information or discussion. Sincerely, o,' Robert N. Thurber Sr. Environmental Analyst cc: (attach distribution list) CA- 7 7,— 'IT 0 tj C.i*;­I Y 7-oom 21 Stony 'Iroo!, �1.77. 117.14 May 15, 1986 TO : Mr. Roy L. Haje 7) T'. Enconsultants 1986 1329 North Sea Rd. Southampton, N.Y. 11968 For: ied-For :1 tj&j Weil 9 as I-oca-tion Protection of Waters A?plication .,.Tu-.'--,er :l 10"486-0647 (Please refer to th'isnum'F—er in all your corre-sj(5nff&--,._ice)_ LT- V017a t-PPLICATIO-1-1 770-tl TI-M, -FE--,7.-IT IS I-�ICOT.TLT=11 j;TTIL T'-"E I'ElUESTED LISTE T IS S1TB­,IT=D TO. TtIIIS 0F2F2IC'_;`1. "ou did not include A7ita -our a-)-.)lication the full of -lec' one--y oun't r, o r r- the requited fee. Ple.a3e cubtuit a c^. 0' be determine t'he liei-7 e r in the amount o ' $t pajable to Y bt-j,, State Department of 7_'nvironmental Conservation. "-lease subi-ait the 'ollo.,Tiin- data: 1. Plans on recent survey zx (or updated survey) as Der checklist Item 741) certified by a licensed surveyor. The survey should Ymx identify all monuments and/orlax- property line set stakes - which the surveyor has used to delineate the property lines which plans should specify the distances in linear feet the nroDosed structure is .to be from the monuments/set stakes (Tor prop Line ' Y 2* Written notice that monument' property line set stakes locations have beem staked or flagged so they can be easily found by DEC field staff and measipements can be verifi ed ti�i_710 stake locations for proposed structure. SLk _a, c C__44 - to It bar. been determined taat your project is subject _i - 4 -7 State o f t e Encironn-eatal Conservat-on La� rticle t'a e Y"our a- -cation. Act onli Raviro-Limental !-ualit- I;.evie7,7 vii 11 be considered coni- lete 7-7hen: zr Tor further information, contact t1_4 S Office. Proiect Bob Thurber 177 U -,..T 1 7; 1i-j yn, p r 'r r-/1 T T d 0-9 ')TT77 -r'7-_,2 7-)7`--.--IT for reiun an. nlication tee. a 171? ®� TELEPHONE (516) 765-1892 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 June 27, 1986 SIGNIFICANT DECLARATION NOTICE OF SIGNIFICANT EFFECT ON THE ENVIRONMENT Pursuant to the provisions of Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation-Law, Part 617 of Title 6 of the New York State Codes, Rules and Regulations, and Chapter 44 of the Southold Town Code, the Southold Town Trustees, as lead agency, does hereby determine that the action described below is a Type 1 Action and is likely to have a significant effect on the environment. APPLICANT: En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of Sal Caiola DESCRIPTION OF ACTION: Appellant proposes to construct a steel retaining wall along the tow of bluff and on uphill side of the road down face of bluff. A total of 962± lin. ft. of retaining wlal is proposed. For sections facing Long Island Sound stone armor will be placed. Approximately 400 cu. yds. of clean sand and loam will be trucked in for backfill. Wall will be entirely above MHW. Property is located on Sound Drive, Greenport. Further information can be obtained by contacting Mr. Henry P.' Smith, President, Board of Town Trustees, Southold Town Hall, Main Road, . Southold, New York 11971 or by calling (516) 765-1892. Copies to: Charles T. Hamilton, D.E.C. , Stony Brook Coinmmissioner Henry G. Williams, D.E.C. , Albany Southold Town Building Dept. Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council Aram Terchunian, Coastal Management Program Town CLerk's Bulleting Board Trustees Alex Lechich; ARmy Corps of Engineers Fy 0(,P��,®/yf� `�// }AMA/�1y�F� -✓�/ t TELEPHONE (516) 765-1892 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 June 27, 1986 Mr. Roy L. Haje, President En-Consultants, Inc. 1329 North Sea Road Southampton, New York 11968 Re: Sal Caiola Wetland Application No. 400 Dear Mr. Haje: The following action was taken by the Board of Trustees at their regular meeting held on June 26, 1986 regarding the above referenced application. WHEREAS, En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of Sal Caiola applied to the Southold Town Trustees, pursuant to Chapter 44 of the Code of the Town of Southold for permission to construct a sheet steel retaining wall along the tow of bluff and on uphill side of road down the face of bluff. A total of 962± lin. ft. of retaining wlal is proposed. For sections facing Long Island Sound stone armor will be placed. Approximately 400 cu. yds. of clean sand and loam will be trucked in for backfill. Wall will be entirely above MHW. Property is located on Sound Drive, Greenport, NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED AS FOLLOWS: 1. Pursuant to the provisions of Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law; Part 617 of Title 6 of . the New York State Code, the Southold Town Trustees, as lead agency, does hereby determine that the action proposed is a Type 1 Action and is likely to have a significant effect on the environment. 2. That the Clerk to the Trustees shall file and circulate such determination as required by the aforementioned law, rules and code. 3. That the Clerk to the Trustees shall immediately notify the agent on behalf of the applicant and further request said applicant to prepare a Draft Environmental Impact Statement all in accordance with said law, rules and code. Ver . truly yours� Henry P. Smith, President Board of Town Trustees Page 3 On a motion made by Ralph Condit , seconded by Jeanne Marriner, it was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees DISAPPROVAL of wetland application No. 398 submitted by En-Consultants , Inc . on behalf of Harold Wilsberg to construct 100 ' timber bulkhead generally along line of MHW plus 15 ' return at west end. Dredge in front out to 151 . Approximately 225 c. y. of spoil will be removed and placed behind the bulkhead as spoil. Bulkhead will correct to and be in line with recently constructed bulkhead to east . 10 year maintenance dredge is requested. The Council would like the applicant to re- submit or amend the application for only a floating dock and no bulkhead. The Council recommends the floating dock instead of the bulkhead to allw for the extensive col:6nization of spartina which would stabilize the land and reduce the nedd for any bulkhead. Ole Jule Lane, Mattituck. Vote of Council: Ayes : Ralph Condit Jeanne Marriner Nays : John Tuthill - John sees _ nothing wrong with the bulkhead. He feels the applicant should be allowed to do what wants to do on his own property. Abstain: John Holzapfel - John has not inspected the property . Motion LOST. On a motion made by Ralph Condit , seconded by Jeanne Parriner , it was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees APPROVAL of wetland application No . 399 submitted by the Land Use Company on behalf of Margaret Cukor to reconstruct within 18" , approximately 122 ' of strom damaged timber bulkhead and backfill with approximately 10c. y . of clean sand. Indian Neck Road, Peconic. Vote of Council: Ayes: All Motion carried . On a motion made by Jeanne Marriner, seconded by Ralph Condit , it- was RESOLVED to recommend to the Southold Town Trustees DISAPPROVAL of wetland application No. 400 submitted by En- Consultants , Inc . on behalf of Sal Caiola to construct a sheet steel retaining wall along tow of bluff and on uphill side of road down face of bluff . A Total of 962 + l . f. of retaining wall is proposed. For sections facing Long Island Sound . stone armor will be placed. Approximately 400 c. y. of clean sand and loam will be used for backfill. Wall will be entirely above MHW. The Council disapproves because there are no other wall in the adjacent area and it feels construction could disturb the bluffs . Greenport . Vote of Council: Ayes : Jeanne Marriner Ralph Condit c�vFFO(� c� Town Hall, 53095 Main Road Q ,r r _. � P.O. Box 1179 TELEPHONE ' ®1 � Southold, New York 11971 (516)765-1801 SOUTHOLD TOWN CONSERVATION ADVISORY COUNCIL June 23 , 1986 To : Southold Town -B-oard of Trustees From: Linda J . Cooper, CAC Secretary The following recommendations were made at the regular meeting of the Southold Town CAC, held June 19 , 1986 : No . 369 - Joseph A. Barbato - Disapprove, suggest applicant resubmit . No . 372 - Donald Brennan - Approve with stipulations ; No. 392 - Mathias Mone - Approval with stipulations No . 393 - Vernon G. Strub - Approve No . 394 - Frank'-R. Teilly - TABLED No. 395 - Roger Vorce - Approval. with stipulations No . 396 - Frederick .Kowhler - Disapprove. No. 397 - Joseph Marrapodi - Approve No. 398 - Harold Wilsberg - No recommendation . No. 399 - Margaret Cukor Approve No. 400 - Sal Caiola - No recommendation No. 401 - Dimitrois J . Sariyiannis - Approve No . 402 - Gerald Rupp - No recommendation. Should you have any questions , please do not hesitate to contact me . HENRY P. SMITH President AY •- JOHN M. BREDEMEYER, Vice-Pres. a ri4° a TELEPHONE PHILLIP J. GOUBEAUD �:.'4 = jr„ : � (516) 765-1892 ALBERT KRUPSKI, JR. e�°r ELLEN M. LARSEN BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 June 6, 1986 En-Consultants, Inc. 1329 North Sea Rd. Southampton, N.Y. 11968 Dear Sirs : RE: Sal Caiola The following action was taken by the Board of Trustees a.t .their meeting held on May 29, 1986 regarding your wetlands application no. 400. Moved by Trustee E. Larson, seconded by Trustee J. Bredemeyer it was RESOLVED that the Southold Town Trustees declare itself lead agency in regard to the State Environmental Quality , Review Act in the matter pf the application of En-Consultants Inc. on behalf of Sal Caiola for a Wetland Permit on certain- property located on Sound Drive, Greenport. Very truly yours , Henry P. Smith, President ,Board of Town Trustees HPS:ao CC: Trustees File BOARD OF .TOWN TRUSTEES 0 n 9 TOWN OF SOUTHOLD � 311 -- 53095 Main Road Phone 765-1892 Southold, N. Y. 119.71 c19� , Date RECEIVED OF �✓� Dollars S^� Q For � ) BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES 1 - B �._✓k cash ❑ Check C"i � I RESOLUTION - May 29, 1986 RESOLVED that the Southold Town Trustees declare itself lead - agency in regard to the State Environmental Quality Review Act in the matter of the application of En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of Sal Caiola for a Wetland Permit on certain property located on Sound Drive, Greenport. T T Ael U-3 . TELEPHONE (516)765-1892 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728' .. Southold, New York 11971 APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE TO THE TOWN TRUSTEES OF THE TOWN .OF SOUTHOLD, SUFFOLK COUNTY, NEW YORK FOR THE ISSUANCE OF A PERMIT PURSUANT TO THE LAW'; ORDINANCES AND. REGULATIONS GOVERNING THE COASTAL AND INTERIOR WETLANDS, FLOQD; PLAINS AND DRAINAGE AREAS OF THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD. AND THE IS'SUANCE .oF PERMITS PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 32 OF THE CODES OF THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD. APPLICATION NO.`4 V v _ DATE OF APPL I CATION April 29, 1986 -- -3r6%2'9=5W75--- IDENTITY OF APPLICANT Sal Caiola- PHONE NO ADDRESS OF APPLICANT- 71 Lynn Avenue Hampton B$ys, New York 11946 TAX MAP NO. Diet. 1000 '. Sec. 033 Block 03 Lot p/o Lot 19 516 283-6360 AGENTr En-Consultants, Inc, PHONE NO._ 1329 North Sea Road Southampton, NY 11968 PERMIT REQUESTED TO (see attached) LOCATION OF PROPERTY FOR WHICH PERMIT WANTED Greenport HOME ADDRESS OF PERMIT APPLICANT urF DIFFERENT FROM AFORESAID LOCATION 71 Lynn Avenue, Hampton ems. New York 11946 — CREEK, BAY OR HARBOR FRONTING PROPERTY SIZE OF PROPOSED WORK See above: LENGTH WIDTH n n 13+ .HEIGHT ABOVE -HIGH WATER ' DEPTH BELOW LOW WATER N/a YARDS TO BE EXCAVATED 0 YARDS TO BE FILLED 400 WIDTH OF CANAL, CREEK OR BAY FRONTING PROPERTY lU+ Mile DEPTH AT LOW- TIDE N/a AVERAGE RISE IN TIDE 2'-611 DISTANCE TO THE NEAREST CHANNEL N/a FT. DISTANCE PROJECT EXTENDS BEYOND SIMILAR PROJECTS IN THE AREA 0 FT. 15 THIS FOR PRIVATE OR BUSINESS USE? private AREA ZONING Residential A MANNER IN WHICH MATERIAL WILL BE REMOVED OR DEPOSITED Trucked in _ dumped and graded. — INTENDED USE OF PROPERTY Residence DESCRIBE ANY KNOWN PRIOR OPE.RAT•IONS CONDUCTED ON THE PREMISE None known AND .WHETHER ANY PR.1 OR­ LICENSE OR PERMITS HAVE BEEN ISSUED TO ERRECT STRUCTURES OR TO DREDGE OR DEPOSIT FILL ON SAID PREMISES AND WHETHER ANY PERMITS OR LICENSES WERE • EVER .SUSPEND.ED - OR REVOKED BY A GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY N/a DESCRIBE FULLY THE REHABILITATION AND PROPOSED CONDITION OF THE PREMISES AFTER THE WORK 1S COMPLETED- INCLUDE AN ADDITIONAL SURVEY OF THE PROJECT SITE IF NECESSARY N/a WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE OWNER OF THE PROPERTY, IF NOT THE SAME AS THE APPLICANT. See attached ARE THERE ANY COVENANTS OR RESTRICTIONS IN YOUR DEED THAT WOULD PROHIBIT THIS PROJECT? None known PROJECT DESCRIPTION Construct a sheet steel retaining wall along tow of bluf� and on uphill side of road down face of bluff. A total of 962- l.f. of retaining wall is proposed. For section. facing Long Island Sound. clean stone armor will be placed. Approximately 400 cualc willardebefcntirely eand and loam will be trucked in for backfill. above - BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES- ,-- TOWN .OF SOUTHOLD SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM Project Information (To be completed by Applicant or Project sponsor) 1. Applicantisponsor 2. Project Name Sal Caiola by En-Consultants, Inc, s. Project location: . Greenport, Town of Southold Suffolk Municipality County 4. Is pigosed action: L_I New ❑ Expansion ❑ Modification/alteration 5. Describe project briefly: (see attached) 6. Precise location(road intersections, prominent landmarks,etc.or provide map) Greenport Town of Southold 7. Amount of land aLfe; d 9,54 • Initially `J [} acres Ultimately acres 8. Will proposed action comply with existing zoning or other existing land use restrictions? IS Yes ❑ No If No,describe briefly 9. What is present land use in vicinity of project? ® Residential ❑ Industrial ❑ Commercial ❑ Agriculture ❑ Parkland/open space ❑ Other Describe: 10. Does action involve a permit/approval,or funding,now or ultimately,from any other governmental agency(Federal,state or local)? © Yes ❑ No If yes, list agency(s)and permit/approvals DEC 11. Does any aspect of the action have a currently valid permit or approval? ❑ Yes ® No If yes, list agency name and permit/approval type 12. As result of proposed action will existing permit/approval require modification? ❑ Yes ® No CERTIFY THAT TH "FORMATION PROVIDED ABOVE 15 TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE Applicant/sponsor name: `Sal Caio a by En on ltants, Inc, Date: April 29,1986 Signature: PROJECT DESCRIPTION Construct a sheet steel retaining wall along tow of bluf and on uphill side of road down face of bluff. A total of 9621 l.f. g Long Island Sound. of retaining wall is proposed. For sections facin aced. Approximately 400 cubic wayards f clean stone armor will be pl entirely sand and loam will be trucked in for backfill. wall will be above KW. JAL <-A loi-A afit';oric7ie En-Consultants , Inc. , to secure any pe�'mits required. , ti r 1 Please sic7n And return. if SvFFo4-K Co. NAGSTAoM n/ MAP ab S s}r GfQ � N lNL � yp� ,BENNC 2 S tM • gO p � i i SOJ I SLP L ' 260: h of f3 LVFF ,,0-JO ' J t N to fah JF(, o �o Q y� 0I- h0 Gi�y tiv � J �y Q < o sb ioo x d r PRO PO SEO 9, TA-1,V/NG r GlA LL For /1aZ�� S 111001-e RoAO 5Ac. CAivLA oh OATvti: HS4- GR V$ LoivG /s L A X 0 5701-114Q Pc.,QP0Sc: of 6;R4CF-,vPoR7" SVFFoL,C EK b5/cN ANT 2oL. Cod � Y S N� C T /•f� y�.� ��sto Y COUNTY OF SUFFOLJC ) STATE OF NEW YORK ) SS: Roy L. Hgje BEING DULY SWORN DEPOSES AND SAYS THAT HE IS THE APPLICANT FOR THE ABOVE DESCRIBED .PERMITS, AND THAT ALL STATEMENTS CONTAINED HEREIN ARE TRUE TO THE BEST OF HIS KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF, THAT THE WORK WILL BE DONE IN THE MANNER SET FORTH IN THIS APPLICATION AND AS MAY BE APPROVED BY THE TOWN BOARD OF THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD. THE APPLICANT AGREES TO HOLD THE TOWN OF SOUTHOLD AND THE TOWN TRUSTEES HARMLESS AND FREE FROM ANY AND ALL DAMAGES AND CLAIMS ARISING UNDER OR BY VIRTUE OF SAID PERMIT, 1F GRANTED. SIGNATI F A PLIC f4T SWORN TO BEFORE ME THIS 29th DAY OF April 19 86 ,9- �g� DOROTHY M. BOYD NOTARY PUBLIC,State of New York NOTAR67PUBLIC No.52-0376615 Qualified in Suffolk County VommiWa Expires March 30,191 EXAMINED APPROVED "WETLANDS" PERMIT (CHAPTER 97) APPROVED "BOAT, DOCKS, WHARVES" PERMIT (CHAPTER 32) DISAPPROVED ,"WETLANDS PERMIT"CHAPTER 97) DISAPPROVED "BOATS, DOCKS, WHARVES" PERMIT CHAPTER 32) CONDITIONS, IF ANY EXAMINING BODY SIGNATURE OF CHAIRMAN COMPUTATION OF FEES ADDroved /27/RS.. TELEPHONE (516) 765-1892 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 May 29, 1986 Mr. Charles T. Hamilton Alternate Regional Permit Administrator N.Y. S. D.E.C. Building 40, SUNY - Room 219 Stony• Brook, New York 11794 Dear Mr. Hamilton: Transmitted herewith is wetland application no.= 400 submitted by En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of Sal Caiola. We would like to coordinate with you in our role -as lead agency regarding this application. May we have your comments on same by June 13, 1986. Thank you for your input. Very truly yours, Henry P. Smith, President Board of Town Trustees Ilene Pfifferling Secretary to Board Attachments cc: Commissioner Williams Southold Town Building Dept. file TELEPHONE (516) 765-1892 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 May 9, 1986 Mr. Martin Garrell, Chairman Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council Southold Town Hall Southold, New York 11971 Dear Mr. Garrell: Transmitted herewith is application no. 400 for a wetland permit submitted by En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of Sal Caiola. Please prepare a written report of findings and recommendations with respect to this application. Very truly yours, Henry P. Smith, President Board of Town Trustees Ilene Pfifferling Secretary to Board Attachment R �, TELEPHONE (516) 765-1892 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 Date: May 9, 1986 To Whom it may concern: Attached hereto is a Short Environmental Assessment Form submitted by En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of Sal Caiola in connection with his application for a Wetland Permit to construct . a steel retaining wall along the tow of bluff and on uphill side of road down face of bluff. A total of 962± lin. ft. of retaining wall is proposed. For sections facing Long Island Sound stone armor will be placed. Approximately 400 cu. yds. of clean sand and loam will be trucked in for backfill . Wall will be entirely above MHW. Property is located off of Sound Drive,' Greenporti enry P. oSmith, resident Board of Town Trustees Posted: May 9, 1986 FOC,��oG s Ln TELEPHONE (516) 765-1892 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 June 27, 1986 SIGNIFICANT DECLARATION NOTICE OF SIGNIFICANT EFFECT ON THE ENVIRONMENT Pursuant to the provisions of Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law, Part 617 of Title 6 of the New York State Oodes, Rules and Regulations, and Chapter 44 of the Southold Town Code, the Southold Town Trustees, as lead agency, does h6reby determine that the action described below is a Type 1 Action and is likely to have a significant effect on the environment. APPLICANT: En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of Sal Caiola DESCRIPTION OF ACTION: Appellant Aproposes to construct a steel retaining wall along the tow of bluff and on uphill side of the road down face of bluff. A total of 962±. lin. ft. of retaining wl&L is proposed. For sections facing Long Island Sound stone armor will be placed. Approximately 400 cu. yds. of clean sand and loam will be trucked, inlfor backfill. Wall will be entirely above MHW. Property is located on. Sound Drive, Greenport. Further information can be obtained by contacting Mr. Henry P. Smith, President, Board of Town Trustees, Southold Town Hall, Main Road, Southold, �= New York 11971 or by calling (516) 765-1892. Copies to: Charles T. Hamilton, D.E.C. , Stony Brook Commmissioner Henry G. Williams, D.E.C. , Albany Southold Town Building Dept. Southold Town Conservation Advisory Council Aram Terchunian, Coastal Management Program Town CLerk's Bulleting Board Trustees ���FFO co TELEPHONE (516) 765-1892 BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 Date: May 9, 1986 To Whom it may concern: Attached hereto is a Short Environmental Assessment Form submitted by En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of Sal Caiola in connection with his application for a Wetland Permit to construct a steel retaining wall along the tow of bluff and on uphill side of road down face of bluff. A total of 962± lin. ft. of retaining wall is proposed. For sections facing Long Island Sound stone armor will be placed. Approximately 400 cu. yds. of clean sand and loam will be trucked in for bac%kfill. Wall will be entirely above MHW. Property is located off of Sound Drive, Greenporti Anry P. Smith, President Board of Town Trustees 4 Posted: May 9, 1986 BOARB' OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN 'OF SOUTHOLD SHORT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT FORM Project Informatlon (To.be completed by Applicant or Project sponsor) 1. Applicant/sponsor 2. Project Name Sal Caiola by En-Consultants, Inc. 3. Project location: • Greenport, Town of Southold Suffolk Municipality County 4. Is pgosed action: New ❑ Expansion ❑ Modification/alteration 5. Describe project briefly: (see attached) 6. Precise location(road intersections,prominent landmarks,etc-or provide map) Greenport Town of Southold 7. Amount of land lec Initial) " ' 9.54 V acres Ultimately acres 8. Will proposed action comply with existing zoning or other existing land use restrictions? ❑ Yes ❑ No If No,describe briefly 9. What is present land use in vicinity of project? ® Residential ❑ Industrial ❑ Commercial ❑ Agriculture ❑ Parkland/open space ❑ Other Describe: 10. Does action involve a permiUapproval,or funding,now or ultimately,from any other governmental agency(Federal,state or local)? ® Yes ❑ No If yes, list agency(s)and permitiapprovals DEC 11. Does any aspect of the action have a currently valid permit or approval? ❑ Yes ® No If yes, list agency name and permit/approval type 12. As result of proposed action will existing permit/approval require modification? ❑ Yes IN No CERTIFY THAT T,jiE INFORMATION PROVIDED ABOVE IS TRUE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE Applicant sponsor name: Sal CaioolS by�E Consultants, Inc. Date: April 29,1986 k Signature: r rt f 1 r PART II Environmental Assessment (To be completed by Agency) A. Does action exceed any Type I threshold in 6 NYCRR,Part 617.12? If yis,coordinate the review process and use the FULLILONG FORM EAF. j ❑ Yes ❑ No f B. Will action receive coordinated review as provided for Unlisted Actions in 6 NYCRR;Part 617.7? If No,a negative declaration may be superceded by another Involved action. ElYes ❑ No C. Could action result in ANY adverse effects on,to,or arising from the following:(Answers may be handwritten, if legible) C1. Existing air quality,surface or groundwater quality or quantity,noise levels,existing traffic patterns,solid waste production or disposal,potential for erosion, drainage or flooding problems? Explain briefly: C2. Historic,archeological,visual or aesthetic,or other natural or cultural resources;agricultural districts;o►community or neighborhood character?Explain briefly: C3. Vegetation or fauna,movement of fish or wildlife species,significant habitats,or threatened or endangered species? Explain briefly: C4. A community's existing plans or goals as officially adopted, or a change in use or,intensity of use of land or other natural resources? Explain briefly. x_ C5. Growth,subsequent development,or related activities likely to be induced by the proposed action?Explain briefly. C6. Secondary,cumulative,or other effects not identified in C7 C6?Explain briefly. C7. A change in use of either quantity or type of energy?Explain briefly. PART III Determination of Significance (To be completed by Agency) INSTRUCTIONS: For each adverse effect identified above, determine whether it is substantial, large;important or otherwise significant. Each effect should be assessed in connection with its(a)setting(i.e. urban or rural); (b) probability of occurring; (c)duration;(d) irreversibility;(e)geographic scope; anc:(f)rllagnitude. If necessary, add attachments or reference supporting materials. Ensure that explanations contain sufficient detail to show'that all relevant adverse'impacts have been identified and adequately addressed. ❑ Check this box if you have identified one or more potentially large or significant adverse impacts which MAY occur. Then proceed directly to the FULL/LONG FORM EAF and/or prepare a positive declaration. ❑ Check this box if you have determined, based on the information and analysis above and any supporting documentation, that the proposed action WILL NOT result in any significant adverse environmental impacts AND provide here, and on attachments as necessary, the reasons supportng this determination: Agency Name Agency Preparer's Name Preparers SignaturerTrtle , Date o��FFot�co HENRY P. SMITH, President p TELEPHONE JOHN M. BREDEMEYER, Vice-Pres. cn PHILLIP J. GOUBEAUD �y (516) 765-1892 ALBERT KRUPSKI, JR. ELLEN M. LARSEN BOARD OF TOWN TRUSTEES TOWN OF SOUTHOLD Town Hall, 53095 Main Road P.O. Box 728 Southold, New York 11971 S.E.Q.R.A. NEGATIVE DECLARATION NOTICE OF NO SIGNIFICANT EFFECT ON THE ENVIRONMENT NAME: EN-CONSULTANTS, INC. FOR SAL CAIOLA. APPLICATION NO. 400 Date: October 30, 1986 This notice is. issued pursuant to the provisions of Article 8 of the Environmental Conservation Law State Environmental Quality Review and 6NYCRR Part 617, Section 617.10 and Chapter 44 of the Code of the Town of Southold, notice is hereby given that the Southold Town Trustees, as lead agency for the action described below has determined that the project will not have a significant effect on the environment. Please take further notice that this declaration should not be considered a determination made for any other department or agency which may also have an application pendl.-ig for the same or similar project. TYPE OF ACTION: TYPE II DESCRIPTION OF ACTION:Appellant proposes to construct a steel retaining wall along the tow of bluff and on uphill side of the .road down the face of the bluff. A total of 962t lin. ft.of retaining wall is proposed. For sections facing Long Island Sound stone armor will be placed. Approximately 400 cu. yds. of clean sand and loam will be trucked in for backfill. Wall will be entirely above MHW. LOCATION OF PROJECT:Sound Drive, Greenport REASONS SUPPORTING THIS DETERMINATION: l. . An environmental assessment form has been submitted which indicated that there would be no adverse effect to the environment should the project be implemented as planned. 2. Because there has been no response in the allotted time from the Southold Town Building Dept. and the New York State D.E.C. it is assumed that there are no objections nor comments from those agencies. Page 2. Sal Caiola Further information regarding this application can be obtained by contacting Mr. Henry P. Smith, President, Board of Town Trustees, Southold Town Hall, Main Road, Southold or by calling (516) 765-1892. cc: Robert A. Greene, D.E.C. , Stony Brook Commissioner Henry G. Williams, D.E.C. , Albany Stephen Mars, Army Corps of Engineers Thomas Hart, Coastal Management Conservation Advisory Council Bldg. Dept. Board of Appeals File Town Clerk's Bulletin Board En-Consultants, Inc. on behalf of Sal Caiola l � o °off 2$� o o NO j/ to 0 � L A N oo i G �QN t'e /• 62 � B.a \% 7.3 42 Jeffy 3C 510�� N Ni �.e _- - N. 74045 ' 20 E. a�� / ` d- _ — — J85.00 �� / Q fi` e /ti7 e ' BEACH O �oP �\� FF " O\ 46 80 8.8 9.1 7.8 3a.a W BOTTOM OF BLUFF / p O U O i I .j� F I 3 o LL lD 41. 7 A0 6 O — ' I C 0 U 40.8 I Q) .. 4 3 2 40. S _ I I co i CC tD 46.n TOP co OD � J. I ! /� I v I I I I (o I a o) a 1ID Illct F-- 6 " WATER MAIN i — O /�/ L47,37 rt 48.2346, 49 SOUND DRIVE LL `\ �! / / I— 46 fnto W 44 i \ - / // / \ LOT. LOT 2 / � - 44 42 / / \ \ \ 1 _ / / AREA 5. 0 ACRES \� \\ _ `n _ -6 " WATER_ MAI N _ _ / AREA 4. 54 ACRES ' W L 38.62 L 39.33 39. 87 —� / //l \� \\ \� \\ // Q2 cr O \ / SOUND DRIVE / _ \ � \ � _� , 44G. 40 Q / 138 � v 36 - - - - - - - / co i wLij N z V- it / Q N 34- I z J I O I \ (��e z a Z cf) ui J cc 3 \ W U Oo = \ ,so ' _ a: o v - ` 0? 2a cn Boa 2 g� 8 w O" W J o I I h0' O '�z o L0 LLJ It o / o LLJ / w t 0 cv> / 0) Q � / W o — w N N a , S. 740 45 120 I W.S. 74 ° 45 20 W. v a 271 . 58' 280.00Lo 0 3 PR 0 PO SE D C6 0 3a MAJOR +' o SUBDIVISION L A N D OF o I "o CA IOLA ) TOPOGRAPHICAL SURVEY OF M I DDL E R 0 A D C• R • 4 8 ) MINOR SUBDISION FOR SA L a RE NNY CAIOLA , J R. . AT GREENPORT NOTE : OUTLINE SURVEY BY OTHERS TOWN OF SOUTHOLD ELEVS . ARE REFE' RENCED TO MEAN SEA LEVEL S OF FOL K COUNTY , N. Y. N. Y. S . LIC . NO. 49668 _ 1000 033 - 03 - P / 0 19 P15CONIC SURVEYORS a ENGINEERS , P. C . SCALE 1 " = 50 ' ( 516 ) 765 - 5020 P. O. Box 909 APR. 2 , 1986 MAIN ROAD SOUTHOLD , N. Y . 11971 . 86 - 170